What happens to the shoes nobody buys?

Finished Nooch sneakers lined up on a shelf in the factory, each pair already ordered

Last updated

They get discounted, donated or destroyed. Destroyed is more common than you think, and you are paying for it.

One in four shoes made this year will never be sold to anybody. Not worn out, not returned, not lost. Simply made, shipped, stored and then dealt with, by a company that guessed wrong.

That sentence is the whole reason this company exists, so it is worth unpacking properly: why the guessing happens, what the three options are when it goes wrong, and who actually pays for it. The answer to that last one is you.

It starts with a guess

Almost every shoe you have ever bought was made before anybody knew whether you wanted it. The industry calls this make-to-stock: forecast demand, produce to the forecast, ship to warehouses, hope.

The forecasting is not incompetent. It is just forecasting, and forecasting misses in both directions. Guess too low and you empty a shelf. Guess too high and you fill a warehouse. Only the second kind of miss becomes a pile.

Which is why the numbers do not add up to honest error. The Dutch research institute RIVM puts the share of shoes that are never sold at 20 to 30 per cent. Bad forecasting on its own would not get you anywhere near that, because half of every miss lands on the other side of the line. The rest is deliberate. Brands pad the guess, because an empty shelf is a lost sale and a full warehouse is only an expensive one. So they make more colours and more sizes than they can sell, on purpose.

The pile is not a mistake. The pile is policy.

Discount, donate or destroy

When the season ends and the shoes are still there, there are exactly three ways out, and each one costs the brand something different.

Discount. Mark it down, mark it down again, move it to an outlet. It works, and it teaches customers to wait for the sale, which makes next season worse.

Donate. The obvious one. Also the one most avoided, because a brand that has spent a decade making a shoe feel exclusive does not want it turning up for free.

Destroy. Which is why this happens at all. Perfectly good shoes, cut up or burned so that nobody can resell them and the price stays where the brand put it. It is legal, it is normal, and it is the part the industry would rather you did not picture: a bin of brand new shoes, slashed, on the way to a landfill.

We should be accurate about the size of that last one, because it is the one brands get accused of most and it is the smallest of the three. RIVM estimates that 1 to 5 per cent of all newly produced shoes are destroyed without ever being worn. That sounds modest until you hold it against 24.6 billion pairs a year. One per cent is about 250 million pairs. Five per cent is well over a billion.

Read that back. It is considered better business to destroy a wearable shoe than to let somebody have it who could not pay full price.

The bill you cannot see

Here is where it gets interesting, because all of that has to be paid for, and there is only one person in this story with a wallet.

Take a shoe that costs 75 euro to make. By the time it reaches a shop it has quietly picked up the cost of everything that did not sell alongside it.

What Cost
Making the shoe 75.00
The ones that will not sell, at 20 per cent 15.00
Sitting in a warehouse, three months at about 2.10 a pair a month 6.30
Money tied up in stock, three months 2.63
Marketing and markdowns to shift the rest 15.00
Writing off what gets destroyed 7.50
Before anybody has added a margin 121.43

That is a modelled example rather than a measurement, and the exact numbers move by brand and by season. But the shape is real and the direction is always the same: a 75 euro shoe arrives at the till at 250 or more, and a meaningful slice of that gap is not design, not leather, not craft. It is the cost of the shoes that failed to find anybody.

You are, in other words, paying for the pairs that got destroyed. You just never see the line item.

The other way round

So we build shoes in the opposite order. You order first. Then it gets made.

That sounds small and it changes everything downstream. There is no forecast, because there is nothing to forecast: the order is the production order. There is no warehouse, because there is nothing to store. There is no end-of-season pile, because there is no pile. And there is nothing to destroy, because every pair that exists already belongs to somebody.

In practice it works like this. We make twice a year, in a spring run and an autumn run. A run needs 500 orders to go ahead and it has one closing date. If a run does not reach 500, everybody gets their money back, without having to ask, and the plants stay plants. When it does, your pair gets made with your size on the ticket, in a factory in Felgueiras we have stood in ourselves, and ships from there.

We keep a small buffer, around 10 per cent, for returns and swaps. That is the honest footnote: not zero, small. It would be smaller still if everybody measured their feet before ordering, because a returned pair is the one way a made-to-order shoe can still end up without an owner.

What it costs you

Time. That is the trade, and we are not going to dress it up.

You cannot have these tomorrow. You order, you wait for the run to close, and then you wait for them to be made by people rather than pulled off a shelf. In exchange, nothing was made on a guess, nothing sat in a warehouse at your expense, and nothing gets cut up at the end of the season.

There is one thing that makes the wait easier, and it is not a trick. Buy your next pair before you desperately need it. In our own customer survey, 87 per cent of people said their current shoes had another three or four months in them. That is about a season, and a season is what a sneaker harvest takes: you order in one and wear them in the next. The wait only hurts if you start it on the day your old ones give up.

Frequently asked questions about unsold shoes and made-to-order

What happens to shoes that do not sell?

They get discounted, donated or destroyed. Discounting is the most common and donation the most avoided, because brands protect the idea that the shoe is worth its price. Destruction is the smallest of the three but far from rare: RIVM estimates 1 to 5 per cent of all new shoes are destroyed unworn, which is hundreds of millions of pairs a year.

How many shoes are never sold?

Between 20 and 30 per cent of everything made, on RIVM's estimate, so roughly one in four. Global production was 24.6 billion pairs in 2025, which puts the unsold share in the billions. Most of those are eventually discounted into the market; a smaller share is destroyed or landfilled without ever being worn.

Why do brands destroy new stock instead of giving it away?

Price. A brand that lets unsold stock out cheaply or for free teaches the market what the shoe is really worth, and undercuts the people who paid full price. Destroying it keeps the price intact. It is a rational decision inside a system that should not exist.

Does made-to-order cost more?

Per pair, it is more expensive to make: no economies of scale, no long production runs. But it removes the overproduction, the warehouse, the markdowns and the write-offs, which is a large part of why a conventional shoe costs what it does. You end up paying for the shoe instead of for the ones that failed.

How long do I have to wait?

Until the run closes, and then until it is made. We run twice a year, in spring and autumn. You see the closing date before you order, and we tell you if anything slips.

What if the run does not reach 500 orders?

Then we do not make it, and you get your money back in full, without having to ask for it.

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next

  • ARTICLE

    What a free return really costs

    Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

  • ARTICLE

    How to clean your Noochies

    A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...

  • ARTICLE

    Life with a Noochie

    What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.