What a free return really costs

Last updated

Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

Free shipping and free returns, try before you buy, order three sizes and send two back. It is presented as service. It is a calculation: the cost of the returns is cheaper than the sales lost by making people think.

The parcel going back is the small part of the bill. The shoe is the big part.

How many orders go back

In Germany, roughly one in six online purchases is sent back. That comes from figures for 2018, when around 490 million products were returned, in research linked to the University of Bamberg. For online shoe orders, the figure we work with is 20 to 30 per cent.

Why shoes come back: the number on the box

Sizing is one of the reasons a pair comes back. A shoe size is not a measurement. For an EU 42, the official size charts of Nike and adidas expect a foot of 25.9 centimetres. Converse expects 27.0 for a Chuck Taylor. Same number, more than a centimetre apart.

That is because shoe brands think in lasts, not feet. A last is the foot-shaped block a shoe is built around, every brand has its own, and the size number refers to the last rather than to you. There is no universal standard forcing a 42 to mean anything in particular.

Add in the different systems, European, UK and US, which do not convert cleanly, and the number on the box becomes a rough suggestion.

Japan has been doing it the sensible way for years: shoe sizes are given in centimetres. So it clearly works. The rest of us are just used to the wrong unit.

So people do the sensible thing with a number they cannot trust. They order two or three sizes and let the returns label sort it out.

What happens to a returned pair

Behind each returned parcel is a whole process. Back in the van, back to the warehouse, unpacked, inspected, cleaned, sometimes repaired, repacked and put back up for sale. Not every returned item makes it back onto the shelf.

The shoe is the bigger part

Every return is a delivery twice over, out and back. That journey has a carbon cost, but it is the smaller part of the story. The bigger part is the shoe. Making a conventional pair of trainers costs around 14 kilograms of CO2 before anybody has worn them once. When a returned pair does not get sold again, that production is what was wasted, on top of the journey.

That is the part the free-returns promise never mentions. A return is not a cancelled purchase. It is a shoe that got made and then nobody wore, which makes it the same problem as overproduction, arriving through a different door. The brand already counted the sale, made the shoe, shipped it twice, and at the end of all that there is a pair of shoes nobody owns.

What we do instead

We make your pair after you order it. There is no wall of boxes in a warehouse to swap from, because nobody else ordered your pair. So a size you guessed is not a quick exchange. It is a shoe that has to be made again, with everything that costs.

So we do not do free returns. We ask for two minutes before you order instead: scan your foot with your phone, try a pair on in Amsterdam, or measure at home. How to find your Noochie size walks you through it.

And if a pair still doesn't fit, we swap it. Every harvest we make a few spare pairs on top, for exactly this. If your size isn't among them, we make it in the next production run. The postage back to us is yours.

Measured against a pair of shoes nobody owns, two minutes with a sheet of paper is an absurdly good trade.

Frequently asked questions about returns

Is returning an online order bad for the environment?

Worse than most people assume, and not mainly because of the van. The return journey is a real cost, but the bigger one is the shoe itself: a conventional pair carries roughly 14 kilograms of CO2 before anyone wears it, and a returned pair that is not sold again wastes that production.

Why do so many online orders get returned?

In Germany roughly one in six online purchases is sent back, based on 2018 figures. Sizing is one of the reasons, and it is one you can fix with a tape measure.

Can I send my Noochies back?

You can exchange them. If your pair doesn't fit, mail returns@nooch.earth and we swap it for your size from the spare pairs of that harvest. If your size isn't among them, we make it in the next production run. The postage back to us is yours.

Sources

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next