What is the footwear industry doing to the planet?

A worker lifting a dyed hide out of a tannery pit, surrounded by vats of coloured liquid

Last updated

From cleared rainforest to a desert visible from space. Every stop a shoe makes, and what it costs along the way.

Every shoe tells the story of our global economy: a hidden tale of environmental destruction, animal cruelty and human exploitation. This is the whole chain, stop by stop, from the forest to the furnace.

Deforestation

Cleared rainforest

Many shoes begin in the Amazon. Loggers cut down ancient trees and land grabbers clear the ground, displacing indigenous communities and small farmers. That land is then sold to cattle ranchers at prices up to a hundred times higher than untouched forest.

Cattle farming drives about 80 per cent of deforestation in the Amazon. Beef is the main product, but leather plays a real part: it represents 5 to 10 per cent of a cow's value, and shoes account for nearly half of all leather products.

Since the 1970s we have lost about 20 per cent of the Amazon, an area larger than France and Germany combined. Scientists warn that losing another 5 per cent could tip it over: less rainfall, more fires, and large parts of the rainforest turning into dry savanna.

And despite bans on products linked to deforestation, leather and meat still slip through, because the lobbying is effective and the accountability is thin.

Factory farming

The story continues in factory farms. Picture hundreds or thousands of cows in crowded spaces, barely able to move or behave naturally. Conditions are poor enough that farms lean on heavy doses of antibiotics to stop disease spreading, which feeds global antibiotic resistance.

Livestock farming accounts for roughly 14.5 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions. The waste pollutes nearby water and degrades soil. At any given moment, more than 23 billion animals are living in these conditions.

The slaughterhouse

Animals already stressed from the farm face transport and slaughter. They are often crammed into trucks without food or water. Many are not properly stunned before being bled out, and remain conscious.

The people doing this work pay for it too. Employees, often from vulnerable backgrounds, work in a relentless and emotionally draining environment, and the psychological toll is documented: post-traumatic stress, depression, anxiety. The need to detach from the violence can turn into numbness, or into aggression outside work.

Waste products such as blood and offal contaminate water and soil. Crowded, unsanitary conditions are also where diseases jump from animals to people.

Tanneries

Tanneries turn hides into leather using chromium salts, which are essential to the process and harmful to everything around it.

They produce enormous quantities of toxic waste, and it frequently ends up in local water. Hazaribagh in Bangladesh is the clearest example: tannery runoff contaminated the Buriganga river, killed the aquatic life in it and poisoned the people living alongside. Workers there, including children as young as eight, were exposed daily. Tansy Hoskins reports in her book Foot Work that around 90 per cent of tannery workers in that district die before the age of fifty.

The global leather trade is worth an estimated 100 billion dollars a year. It is not a harmless byproduct of meat. It is a driver of the system that produces it.

The plastic factory

Most shoes today are largely plastic, which comes out of factories that are themselves major polluters. Plastic production alone accounts for nearly 3.8 per cent of global greenhouse gases.

Making it releases microplastics, small enough to be almost impossible to control. They end up in oceans, in soil, and in us. In one study, researchers found plastic particles in the blood of 17 out of 22 people tested.

Since the 1950s production has gone from about 2 million tonnes a year to roughly 450 million. A single sneaker can contain up to 65 separate parts, most of them plastic, and almost none of it is recyclable once it has been glued together. Only about 9 per cent of all plastic ever made has been recycled. Some shoe soles can take a thousand years to break down.

The sweatshop

In the lowest-cost factories the day often starts at 7am with no set end, which turns into unpaid overtime. The rooms are dark and full of fumes from glues and dyes, with poor ventilation. In winter the heating might run for thirty minutes. In summer the heat makes people faint.

A factory near Ho Chi Minh City showed how far it can go: workers exposed to chemicals at levels between 6 and 177 times the legal limit, on 65-hour weeks.

There is usually no canteen, so people eat at their stations during a twenty-minute break. The global clothing and footwear industry employs around 60 million people, about 80 per cent of them women, usually between 18 and 35, often recently arrived from the countryside.

Pay tells the rest. In Ethiopia a shoe worker might earn 24 euro a month. In Pakistan the minimum for unskilled work is around 129 euro a month, and homeworkers often make 20 to 25 per cent of that. Families stitch uppers at home for less than 7 euro a day, keeping solvent-based glues in the rooms where they live. Children work too, some as young as six.

None of this is an accident. As brands push costs down, factories push the burden onto the people with the least power.

Dump and burn

The industry makes about 24.6 billion pairs of shoes a year.

Most are made from materials that do not break down. They sit in landfill for decades, leaking chemicals into soil and water. A large share of discarded footwear from Western countries is exported, where it often ends up in landfill or burned in the open, releasing dioxins and furans into the air.

Chile has become one of the main dumping grounds: huge piles of clothing and footwear accumulate in the Atacama Desert, some of it never worn, tags still attached. And despite the recycling schemes brands advertise, many shoes donated for recycling are landfilled or burned instead.

And underneath all of it

The shoe industry is a clear example of a system that puts profit ahead of people and the planet. Large corporations are structured to maximise shareholder returns, and there is no legal obligation to behave ethically while doing it.

So production moves to countries with weak labour and environmental law, where the consequences are somebody else's. Workers, especially women and children, carry the cost. Natural habitats are cleared, resources depleted, emissions raised.

The scale of the gap is hard to picture until you put numbers on it. Michael Jordan has earned more from a single shoe brand deal than all of that brand's factory workers in Malaysia combined. To match the fortune of that brand's founder, someone on an average Western European salary would need to work for roughly 768,000 years. For the lowest-paid shoe factory workers, 135 million.

The root cause is a system built around short-term profit. Everything above follows from it.

What to do with this

If you have read this far, you know more about how shoes are made than almost anybody buying them. That is worth passing on.

If you want the shorter versions, start with who actually makes your shoes, what happens to the ones nobody buys, and how much carbon is in a pair.

Sources

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next

  • ARTICLE

    What a free return really costs

    Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

  • ARTICLE

    How to clean your Noochies

    A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...

  • ARTICLE

    Life with a Noochie

    What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.