How sustainable are your shoes, really?

A shoemaker at a stitching machine in the Felgueiras factory

Laatst bijgewerkt

"Eco" is on every box now. Here is what each material actually does, and where it ends up.

How sustainable are shoes, really?

Most shoes are not as sustainable as the label suggests. A shoe is dozens of parts glued into one block, and a single recycled lace can earn an eco tag for a sole, lining and glue that are pure plastic. The honest measure is the whole shoe, not its best part.

There is no referee for the word eco. No single rule decides what a sustainable shoe is, so the word has been stretched until one recycled lace can green a shoe whose sole, glue and lining are still plastic. And a shoe is only ever as honest as its worst part.

So this is the map. What each material in your shoe actually is, the good and the catch, and where it ends up when you are done with it. If you want the size of the problem before the detail, what the footwear industry is doing to the planet is the wider picture. Read both and you can see straight through the marketing and decide for yourself. We make shoes too, from plants, so we will show you ours at the end, worst part included. But first, the lineup.

Why eco is hard to trust

Because there is no fixed definition, the claims do the talking: the vague words, the self-made labels, the green leaf printed on a plastic box. New EU consumer rules are now tightening exactly this, by treating environmental claims as things you have to substantiate rather than decorate a label with. Until that bites, the word on the box tells you almost nothing.

The lineup: five materials, five stories

Leather: the old default

Leather is the aristocrat of the lineup, prized for how it looks and how long it lasts, and quiet about where it comes from. Its real cost sits out of sight: in the farming behind it, and the tanning in front of it. The FAO puts the global livestock sector at about 14.5 per cent of all human-caused greenhouse gas emissions, which puts leather among the heaviest-footprint materials in fashion once you count the farming. Tanning then treats the hide so it can never rot, a chemical-heavy step that is hard on local water and on the people living near the tanneries.

The industry argues leather is a by-product of meat and should count more lightly. It is a real debate, and the full story, chemistry and human cost included, lives in our vegan sneakers guide.

Vegan leather: the understudy made of oil

Swap leather for vegan leather and you usually meet its understudy: PU or PVC. That is plastic, made from fossil fuels. It spares the animal, which matters, but you are essentially wearing oil: on our own sums, somewhere between half a litre and a litre of crude goes into a typical synthetic pair. It sheds microplastics as you walk, and at the end it returns to nothing. A synthetic sole can sit in a landfill for hundreds, even up to a thousand, years.

How much of a shoe is secretly plastic, and where it hides, is the subject of plastic-free shoes: do they really exist?

Fruit and bio-leathers: the promising newcomer

The newer fruit leathers from apple, cactus or pineapple are the newcomer everyone wants to believe in. Look closely and most are part plant, part plastic, often only a fifth to a half plant matter, with polyurethane making up the rest. And the leather is only the upper. The sole, glue and lining are usually still synthetic. A real step, just not the whole shoe yet.

Recycled materials: the loop that is still a loop

Recycled bottles in a shoe sound like an exit, and using less virgin plastic is genuinely better. But recycled plastic is still plastic. It sheds the same microplastics, and a shoe made from it can almost never be recycled again. It slows the trip to landfill. It does not cancel it.

Why almost no shoe can actually be recycled is its own uncomfortable answer: can you actually recycle shoes?

Plant-based: the one built to go home

The last one in the lineup is the odd one out, because it is built to lose. Make the whole shoe from plants, with nothing engineered to resist breaking down: natural fibres and natural rubber in place of plastic. The promise is not that it vanishes overnight. It is that what rubs off as you wear it is plant matter rather than fragments that linger. How completely and how fast is the part that serious makers measure rather than slogan.

What that actually means in the ground is on do plant-based shoes really return to nature?

The shoe materials, side by side

One word, eco, covers all five. Here is what they actually are.

Material Animal-free Free of fossil plastic What happens at the end
Leather No Usually no (synthetic sole, glue) Treated never to rot; the plastic parts linger
Vegan leather (PU/PVC) Yes No Sheds microplastics, returns to nothing
Fruit or bio-leather Yes Partly (often part PU) Mixed; the plastic share stays behind
Recycled plastic (rPET) Yes No Sheds microplastics, rarely recyclable again
Plant-based (Nooch) Yes Yes, apart from one bio-based part Not yet known. We research it with universities and colleges

No single column decides it. A shoe can be animal-free and still be all plastic. The honest read is the whole row, not one tick.

The part no material can fix

Every row in that table is about what a shoe is made of. None of them touches how many get made. Between a fifth and a third of all shoes produced are never sold to anybody, and what happens to those is the part of the footprint no material swap can reach. A shoe that was never wanted is a hundred per cent waste whatever it is made of.

Two more questions sit beside materials. Does a shoe that lasts longer help? Sometimes, and durable vs sustainable shoes looks at when it does not. And what happens once a shoe is worn out, and why we lean towards take-back, is in what happens to worn-out shoes.

Where Nooch fits

We will be straight, because we make one of these. A Nooch is built from eight plants and a fungus, with no animal leather anywhere. The sole is natural-rubber based. The upper is a grown sheet of wood cellulose and natural rubber with a fungal component in it, which is not the same thing as mushroom leather and we do not call it that. The laces are organic cotton, the thread is linen, the glue is water based. And it is made after you order it, not before.

And the worst part, since that is the test this page just set. One component, the thin strobel layer under the insole, is PLA spun from corn starch. Bio-based, not from oil, and still a plastic under EU law. It is on the list to replace and we are not going to pretend it is not there.

Biodegradable is a regulated word, and proving it for a whole shoe takes evidence we do not have. So we measure rather than print: we work with universities and colleges on how our materials actually behave, students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university), and we will publish what we learn, whatever it says. The part-by-part detail is its own page.

What to actually look for

Next time a shoe calls itself eco, look past the word and ask:

  • Which part? A recycled lace does not make a plastic shoe green. Check the sole, the glue and the lining, not just the headline material.
  • Plastic or not? If the sole, glue or lining is synthetic, it sheds microplastics while you wear it and lingers for centuries after.
  • Fragments or food? Breaks down can mean it crumbles into microplastic, or that it becomes food for soil. Those are opposites.
  • How long, under what conditions? Biodegradable with no timeframe and no test behind it is just a word.
  • Does the brand name its own worst part? The ones that do are usually telling the truth about the rest.
  • Does it show its sums? A brand that gives you a number and the arithmetic behind it is easier to check than one that gives you a badge.
  • Was it made before anybody wanted it? Forecast production is why so many shoes are never sold, and that waste is invisible on any material label.
  • Will it actually fit? A returned pair often never gets sold again, so the greenest order is the one that does not come back. Measure your feet in centimetres before you choose a size.
  • Who made it, and how? Who actually makes your shoes follows a single pair through every pair of hands it passes.
  • How much carbon, and from where? Most of a synthetic shoe's footprint sits in the factory's energy, not its logo. More in our guide to the carbon footprint of shoes.

The whole point of a map is that you stop trusting the signpost and start reading the ground. The honest shoe is not the one with the best word on the box. It is the one whose worst part you would still be happy to put in the ground.

Frequently asked questions about sustainable shoes

How sustainable are most shoes, really?

Less than the label suggests. Most shoes mix leather or plastic with synthetic soles, glue and linings, and a single recycled or plant-based part is often enough to earn an eco tag for the whole thing. The honest measure is the whole shoe, not its best component.

What is the most sustainable shoe material?

There is no single winner. Leather carries a heavy farming and tanning footprint, synthetic and vegan leather is fossil-based plastic, and even fruit leathers and recycled plastics are usually part synthetic. The most honest direction is a whole shoe made of plant materials that can return to nature, made under fair conditions.

Is vegan leather sustainable?

Not automatically. Most vegan leather is PU or PVC, which is plastic from fossil fuels. It avoids the animal, but it sheds microplastics and does not return to nature. Plant-based leathers are better but are often still part plastic.

Are recycled shoes sustainable?

Better than virgin plastic, but not a clean answer. Recycled plastic still sheds microplastics, and a shoe made from it can rarely be recycled again, so it usually ends up in landfill anyway.

What makes a shoe biodegradable?

More than the word. A material only counts if a set amount breaks down within a set time under set conditions, and many biodegradable plastics simply fragment into microplastic. We explain the difference on our returns-to-nature page.

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next