Plastic-free shoes: do they really exist?

A hand holding a curved reinforcement piece for the heel of a shoe, one of the parts where plastic usually hides

Laatst bijgewerkt

Almost none do. The plastic just hides where you cannot see it.

Here is the question almost no shoe has to answer: did any part of this start as oil? Vegan does not ask it. Eco does not ask it. So a shoe can be sold as natural, vegan or conscious and still be mostly plastic, and not in the part you would think to check. It hides in the quiet parts: the foam in the sole, the thread stitched through the whole shoe, the glue holding it together, the coating on the plant-based leather. A truly plastic-free shoe has to catch every one of them, not just the upper. That is rare, and it is hard. We know, because we tried and we are not all the way there.

What plastic-free actually means

No synthetic, oil-based material anywhere in the shoe. No polyester, no nylon, no PU, no EVA, no PVC. Not in the upper, not in the sole, not in the thread or the glue.

It is a stricter test than vegan. Vegan only asks whether anything came from an animal, which means a vegan shoe can be made almost entirely of plastic and still earn the label. Plastic-free asks the harder version of the same question, of every single part.

Most shoes never get asked that question. So most shoes never have to answer it.

Label What it promises What is actually in it
Vegan No animal materials Often all plastic
Recycled plastic Made from old plastic Still plastic
Plastic-free No oil-based materials None

Where the plastic hides

Some of it you would guess. Most of it you would not. A typical pair of running shoes is built from 65 separate parts and more than 360 production steps, according to a life-cycle study by MIT. That is a lot of places for plastic to live.

The sole. The springy midsole in almost every trainer is EVA, a plastic foam made from oil. The grippy outsole is usually synthetic rubber or TPU. This is also the part that wears down the most: every step grinds off tiny fragments, and shoe-sole abrasion is now recognised as a real and under-counted source of microplastics. The footwear research body SATRA traces shoe microplastics to outsoles, plasticised uppers, laces, fasteners and the finishes on textiles and leather.

The upper. The wolf in plant clothing. Knit uppers are usually polyester, and even leather-look and plant-based uppers are normally finished or bound with PU to make them durable. That is why an apple-leather or fungus-based upper can still be mostly plastic.

The thread. The one nobody suspects. The stitching that holds a shoe together is, by default, polyester or nylon. Plastic, running through the entire shoe, invisible.

The glue. The saboteur. Shoes are held together with synthetic adhesives, and it is also the reason shoes cannot really be recycled: once every part is glued into one block, you cannot separate them again. National Geographic has described most shoes as a glued-together mix of plastics that, bonded into a single block, is almost impossible to recycle and persists for hundreds of years.

The small stuff. Heel counters, toe puffs, eyelets, finishes and coatings. Even well-made leather shoes often have thin plastic strips hidden inside at the heel and the sole edge.

Add it up and the picture is clear. A shoe does not have to look like plastic to be made of it.

A trail of microplastics, one step at a time

You do not have to throw a shoe away for it to shed plastic. It happens while you wear it. Soles wear down, synthetic threads and uppers shed microfibres, and the fragments end up in soil and water. Independent field research has measured shoe-sole abrasion shedding microplastics onto trails, with the main types being polyurethane, polyester and nylon, the same plastics found in the sole, the upper and the thread. A peer-reviewed study in the Journal of Hazardous Materials found that fragments from sneaker soles reduced the soil's ability to hold water and slowed plant growth.

So a plastic shoe is not only a problem at the end of its life. It leaves a little of itself behind with every step.

So do plastic-free shoes exist?

A few. Not many.

Recycled-plastic shoes do not count. Recycled polyester is still plastic: it still sheds microplastics, and once it is glued to the rest of the shoe it still cannot be recycled again. It is a better use of plastic, not an absence of it. When RunRepeat analysed 89 eco-sneakers, the carbon savings were marginal across the board. Their verdict, in their own words: all eco sneakers do is kill the planet a little bit slower.

Natural and plant-based shoes usually do not count either, because the sole, the thread or the glue is still synthetic even when the upper is not.

A genuinely plastic-free shoe is rare because it means solving every one of those hidden parts. A handful of small makers have shown it can be done. WAES, for one, developed its own hemp, cotton and flax thread to replace the standard PU thread, and a tree-resin glue instead of a synthetic one. The brand has since wound down, but the point holds: it just takes redesigning the parts nobody else questions.

How to tell if a shoe is actually plastic-free

You will not find it on the front of the box. Check the material list instead, and look past the upper.

  • The sole: is it natural rubber, or EVA, TPU and synthetic rubber?
  • The thread: most brands will not even list it. If it is not named, assume polyester.
  • The upper: vegan leather, PU, microfibre and recycled polyester are all plastic. Hemp, organic cotton, linen and genuinely plant-based materials are not.
  • The glue and finishes: rarely listed. A brand that has solved its glue tends to say so, because it was hard.

If a shoe is truly plastic-free, the brand will usually tell you in detail, because getting there was the whole point.

How far we got, and where we stopped

To get to zero, every part has to be rethought. The sole becomes natural-rubber based instead of EVA. The thread gets spun from plants instead of nylon. The glue, the upper, the lining, the coating: each one swapped for something that started as a plant.

We did almost all of it. The sole is natural-rubber based. The thread is linen and cotton. The glue is water based. The lace tips are cellulose instead of hard plastic, and the stiffener in the toe is cotton with plant latex rather than a synthetic sheet. Those are the four parts where nearly everybody quietly keeps the plastic.

And then there is one we have not solved. The thin strobel layer under the insole is PLA, spun from corn starch. So we do not say plastic-free. Not with an asterisk, not with an apart-from. One part to go, and when it changes, the passport of every pair changes with it.

Why a plastic made from plants is still plastic

This is the part worth understanding, because it is where most brands get creative and we would rather just explain it.

What PLA is

PLA stands for polylactic acid. You take sugar from a plant, in our case corn starch, and ferment it into lactic acid. That is the same lactic acid that makes yoghurt sour. Then you link those small molecules into long chains, and long chains are what a polymer is. A polymer you can shape and build with is a plastic.

So the carbon in it grew in a field this year, rather than sitting underground for three hundred million years. That is a real difference and it is why we use it.

Why the law does not care where the carbon came from

European law defines plastic by what the molecule is, not by what it was made from. The single-use plastics rules say so explicitly: a material built from a polymer that can act as a main structural component counts as plastic, and bio-based and biodegradable plastics are included on purpose.

We think that rule is right, even though it costs us a word we would like to use. If the definition followed the feedstock instead of the molecule, a brand could swap corn for oil in the recipe, change nothing about how the material behaves, and print plastic-free on the box. The rule exists to stop exactly that, and we are not going to complain about a rule that protects the buyer from the kind of claim we spend this whole site arguing against.

Bio-based and biodegradable are two different questions

They get used as if they are the same word. They are not. Bio-based says where the carbon came from. Biodegradable says what happens at the end. A material can be one without the other, and PLA is the clearest example: it is bio-based, and whether it breaks down depends entirely on the conditions. In an industrial composter at around 60 degrees it does. In a cool garden it mostly sits there.

Does it shed microplastics while you wear it?

Here is the honest answer, and it is about location rather than material. PLA can fragment, like any plastic. But the strobel is a thin layer sealed inside the shoe, between the insole and the sole. Nothing walks on it. Nothing rubs against it. The parts of a shoe that shed are the parts that meet the ground and the parts that meet your sock, and on a Nooch those are a natural-rubber based sole, linen, cotton and kenaf.

What happens to that layer at the very end, once the shoe is finished, is one of the things our research with universities and colleges is there to find out. We are not going to tell you before we know.

Why it is still in there

The strobel is the layer the upper is stitched to before the sole goes on. It takes the pull of the lasting machine and then the load of every step for the life of the shoe. It has to be thin, strong and dimensionally stable, and the plant-based alternatives we have tested so far give up on at least one of those. It is on the list, and it is the last one.

An ordinary shoe keeps its plastic in the parts you never check. We would rather tell you exactly where ours is, what it is made of, and why it is not gone yet.

Frequently asked questions about plastic-free shoes

Do plastic-free shoes exist?

Yes, but they are rare. Most shoes sold as natural or vegan still have a synthetic sole, thread or glue. A truly plastic-free shoe has solved every one of those parts, which only a handful of makers have done.

Is a Nooch plastic-free?

No, and we would rather say so than stretch the word. Everything in it is plant or natural except one part: the thin strobel layer under the insole, which is PLA spun from corn starch. It is bio-based and it still counts as plastic in EU law. It is on the list to replace. The sole, the thread, the glue, the lace tips and the toe stiffener, which is where most shoes hide theirs, are all sorted.

Is bio-based plastic still plastic?

Yes. European law defines plastic by the polymer, not by the raw material, and bio-based plastics are included on purpose. A plastic grown from corn behaves like a plastic, so it is treated like one. That is why we say free of fossil plastic rather than plastic-free.

Does the PLA in a Nooch shed microplastics?

Not while you wear it. The strobel is a thin layer sealed inside the shoe, with the insole above it and the sole below it, so nothing abrades it. Shedding comes from the surfaces that meet the ground and your foot, and on a Nooch those are a natural-rubber based sole, linen, cotton and kenaf.

Are recycled-plastic shoes plastic-free?

No. Recycled plastic is still plastic. It sheds microplastics, and once it is glued into a shoe it still cannot be recycled. It is a better use of plastic, not an absence of it.

Is vegan the same as plastic-free?

No. Vegan means no animal materials. A vegan shoe can be made almost entirely of plastic. Plastic-free means no oil-based material at all, anywhere in the shoe.

What is a plastic-free sole made of?

A natural-rubber based material, from the rubber tree, instead of the EVA or synthetic rubber used in almost every trainer.

Do natural or plant-based shoes still contain plastic?

Usually yes. The upper may be plant-based while the sole, thread, glue or coating is still synthetic. Plant-based leathers are often bound with PU to make them last.

How can I tell if a shoe is plastic-free?

Check the full material list, not just the upper. Look at the sole, the thread and the glue. If a brand has gone fully plastic-free, it will usually say so in detail.

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next

  • ARTIKEL

    What a free return really costs

    Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

  • ARTIKEL

    How to clean your Noochies

    A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...

  • ARTIKEL

    Life with a Noochie

    What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.