What happens to worn-out shoes, and why we lean towards take-back

Laatst bijgewerkt

Most worn-out shoes go in the bin. The five ways a shoe can end, what is known about each, and why take-back is the route we lean towards.

Most worn-out shoes go in the bin. In the Netherlands about three quarters end up in residual waste, which is incinerated. A shoe is built from many materials glued together, and almost nobody is set up to take it apart.

Take-back is the one route where the brand sees the shoe again. That is why we lean towards it. It is not a solution on its own: it only helps if something useful happens to the shoe afterwards.

Where worn-out shoes go today

RIVM, the Dutch national institute for public health and the environment, reports that about 25 per cent of worn shoes in the Netherlands end up in textile collection and about 75 per cent in residual waste, which is incinerated (RIVM 2026-0099, citing Rebel, 2024).

Of what is collected, 15 per cent is third-grade, dirty or broken, and exported to Pakistan. About half of that is resold after repair, the rest is landfilled (RIVM 2026-0099).

Recycling is not the way out yet. As far as RIVM knows, shoe recycling does not take place on a commercial scale, and the Netherlands has one official shoe recycler (RIVM 2026-0099). Worldwide, about 95 per cent of the roughly 20 billion pairs made each year end up in landfill (Loughborough University, 2013). The industry's own testing body says the same in plain words: shoes put in municipal waste are likely to be landfilled or incinerated (SATRA, 2023). We looked at the same question, with the tracker experiment, in can you actually recycle shoes?

Five ways a shoe can end

Route What it needs What we know
Landfill or incineration Nothing. It is the default EU waste law allows leather waste and chrome shavings to be incinerated or landfilled (Bonilla-Espadas et al., 2024)
Reuse and resale A shoe still in good shape, and a buyer Second-hand shoes are widely seen as unhygienic, which limits demand and sends worn shoes to the bin (RIVM)
Mechanical recycling A shoe that can be separated into its materials A 2024 conference poster puts it at a competitive environmental cost compared with landfill or incineration, if the shoe is redesigned for recovery (Mateu-Romero et al., 2024). A poster, not a full study
Composting Controlled conditions and a plant that accepts shoes SATRA says compostability is increasingly considered. An interviewed company told RIVM there is currently no infrastructure to process post-consumer shoes that are fully biodegradable
Soil A material that breaks down where it lies, and proof that it does Not shown for a whole shoe. The test is the hard part

We did not measure any of these for our own shoe. The table is what others have found.

Why take-back

Three reasons, in order of weight.

There is nowhere obvious to send a shoe like ours. If the infrastructure for plant-based shoes does not exist yet, the brand has to hold the shoe itself, or it ends up in the bin like the other 75 per cent.

Take-back makes the other routes work. SATRA notes that a shredding or grinding solution is typically accompanied by a take-back scheme, so that getting the shoe to the right place is easy for the consumer (SATRA, 2023).

It tells us what a worn shoe really looks like. A shoe that has been walked on for a year is different from one on a test bench.

The law is moving the same way. Directive (EU) 2025/1892 entered into force on 16 October 2025 and requires Member States to give producers extended producer responsibility for textile, textile-related and footwear products. It does not, according to a compliance consultancy, create a general in-store take-back obligation. So today, take-back is a choice. Soon, paying for the end of a shoe's life will be a duty.

What take-back does not do

It does not make a shoe sustainable by existing. A shoe sent back still has to go somewhere. A return parcel has a footprint, and we have not quantified ours. A scheme without a named destination moves the problem from your bin to the brand's warehouse.

Where we stand

Worn-out Noochies can be sent back. The pair goes into our research, and the sender gets 12.50 euro toward the next pair.

What we do not have yet is a verified end destination for the returned shoes. Which of the routes above fits our shoe, we don't know yet. We work with universities and colleges on it, and students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university). We will publish what we learn, whatever it says.

Why a longer life is not the same as a better ending is in durable vs sustainable shoes. Both sit inside a bigger map, how sustainable are your shoes, really? Every part of the shoe is on the published bill of materials. If something there does not match what we wrote, tell us.

Five questions to ask a brand that offers take-back or says "recyclable"

  • What happens to the shoe after it is returned, and who does it? A named process, not "recycled responsibly".
  • What share of returned shoes actually goes there?
  • Who pays for the return shipping, and what does the parcel cost the planet?
  • Does the shoe have to be separated first, and by whom?
  • Where is the result published?

Frequently asked questions about worn-out shoes

What happens to old shoes in the Netherlands?

About 25 per cent go into textile collection and about 75 per cent into residual waste, which is incinerated (RIVM).

Can sneakers be recycled?

Rarely at scale. RIVM says shoe recycling does not take place on a commercial scale, and the Netherlands has one official shoe recycler.

Is take-back required by law?

Not as a general in-store obligation. EU rules on extended producer responsibility for footwear are coming, and Member States set up the schemes.

What does Nooch do with returned shoes?

They go into our research. We do not yet have a verified end destination, and we will say so when we do.

Sources

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next

  • ARTIKEL

    What a free return really costs

    Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

  • ARTIKEL

    How to clean your Noochies

    A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...

  • ARTIKEL

    Life with a Noochie

    What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.