What is a plant-based shoe actually made of?

An off-white Nooch sneaker with the tongue label visible, unlaced on the factory bench

Laatst bijgewerkt

A shoe is dozens of parts. Here is every one of ours, in plain sight.

Take an ordinary sneaker apart and you find a quiet pile of plastic. A synthetic sole, nylon thread, plastic lace tips, petroleum glue, usually under a layer of leather or something sold as vegan leather. Almost none of it is visible from the outside, which is exactly how it gets sold as green.

A shoe is only as honest as its smallest part. So we rebuilt those parts out of things that grew. Here is every one of them, what it replaces, and the one part we have not solved yet.

Why the small parts matter

A cotton shirt sewn with polyester is a polyester product too

This is where a lot of sustainable products quietly fall apart. A shirt can be organic cotton and stitched with polyester thread, or finished with a nylon label, and those few grams shed microplastics for the rest of its life.

A shoe has dozens of hiding places: the thread, the lace tips, the glue, the stiffener in the toe. The headline material gets the attention and the plastic sits in the parts nobody reads out loud. That is why the list below goes all the way down to the tips of the laces.

Inside the shoe, part by part

Same shoe, two completely different material systems.

Part Ours The standard sneaker
Upper Hyphalite, a grown sheet of wood cellulose and natural rubber with a fungal component in it Animal leather, or polyurethane sold as vegan leather
Sole Natural-rubber based, from a tree, and it contains no plastic Synthetic rubber or EVA foam, made from oil
Insole Kenaf fibre, natural rubber and linen EVA foam, made from oil
Laces and lining Organic cotton Polyester and nylon
Lace tips Cellulose Hard plastic
Thread Linen and cotton Nylon or polyester
Glue Water based latex Petroleum based
Toe stiffener Cotton impregnated with plant latex Synthetic sheet
Strobel layer under the insole PLA, spun from corn starch Polyester

The one part that is still plastic

Look at the last row again. That thin layer under the insole is PLA, and it deserves a proper explanation rather than a footnote.

What PLA actually is

Corn starch is sugar. Feed that sugar to bacteria and they turn it into lactic acid, which is the same substance that makes yoghurt sour and the same substance your legs make when you run up a hill. Join a few thousand of those together into a chain and you have a fibre you can spin. There is no barrel of oil anywhere in that sentence.

Why it is still plastic, officially

Because European law says so, and it says so on purpose. In the EU rules, plastic is defined by what the material is, a polymer with additives in it, and not by where the carbon came from. The European Commission has been explicit that bio-based and compostable plastics are included. A chain of molecules is a chain of molecules whether it started in a cornfield or a drill.

We think that is a sensible rule, even though it is inconvenient for us. It is the rule that stops a lot of nonsense.

So we do not say plastic-free

Not plastic-free with an asterisk. Not virtually plastic-free. Not plastic-free apart from. The rule exists precisely because of asterisks, so we do not get to use one. What the word is supposed to mean, and how few shoes anywhere actually clear it, is a question with a post of its own.

What it is not

It is not made from oil. It contains no PFAS, the fluorinated chemicals used across the shoe industry to make things water-repellent, for the simple reason that there is no fluorine in it anywhere. And it is not the polyester that grinds off a synthetic outsole every time you take a step: this layer sits sealed inside the shoe, under the insole, where nothing rubs it against the pavement.

What happens to it at the very end, in real soil rather than an industrial composter, is one of the things we want further research with universities and colleges to look at. We are not going to answer that one ourselves, and we are not going to call it compostable until somebody with a test report says it is.

It is on the list to replace. The day it changes, the passport of every pair changes with it.

What happens at the end

This is the question everybody asks next, and it is the one where most brands reach for a word they cannot back up. We do not use that word. What happens to a Nooch at the end of its life, we do not know yet. We work with universities and colleges to find out, students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university), and we will publish what we learn, whatever it says. The longer version is on the return to nature page.

What the old way leaves behind

The right hand column of that table is not a list of materials. It is a bill.

  • About 24.6 billion pairs of shoes were made in 2025, according to the industry's own yearbook.
  • Researchers at Loughborough University put the share that ends up in landfill at around 95 per cent.
  • One in four is never sold at all. Made, shipped, stored, destroyed, never worn by anybody.
  • A typical pair takes 65 separate parts and more than 360 production steps to put together, on MIT's count.

How much oil is in a pair? Here are our sums

An average synthetic pair holds somewhere around a litre of crude oil. We could not trace that figure to a primary source, so here is our own arithmetic instead of somebody else's number. A pair weighs about 650 grams. Roughly 60 per cent of that is fossil-derived polymer: the EVA midsole, the synthetic rubber, the PU, the polyester. Making a kilo of that polymer takes somewhere between 1.2 and 2 kilos of oil, depending on whether you count only the oil in the material or also the oil burned to make it. That lands between half a litre and one litre per pair. A large glass of crude oil, in a thing you put on your feet and throw away within a year. Check our sums if you like.

We make ours out of plants, and only after you have ordered it, which is the other half of the same answer.

Frequently asked questions about plant-based shoe materials

What is a plant-based shoe made of?

Plant and natural materials in place of plastic and leather. Organic cotton laces and lining, a grown sheet for the upper, linen and cotton thread, a natural-rubber based sole, kenaf fibre in the insole, and a water based glue. Every part down to the lace tips has a plant answer, with one exception we name below.

Is a plant-based shoe completely plastic-free?

Ours is not, and we would rather say so. One part, the thin strobel layer under the insole, is PLA: corn sugar fermented into lactic acid and spun into a fibre. Under European law that counts as plastic, because the rules define plastic by what the molecule is and not by where the carbon came from, and bio-based plastics are included deliberately. So we do not say plastic-free. What we can say is that it is not made from oil, that it contains no PFAS, and that it sits sealed inside the shoe rather than on a wear surface.

How much oil is in a pair of trainers?

Somewhere between half a litre and a litre of crude for a typical synthetic pair, on our own estimate. The figure you see quoted around the internet has no primary source we could find, so we worked it out ourselves and showed the arithmetic above rather than repeat a number we cannot stand behind.

Is PLA bad for the environment?

It is better than fossil plastic on the way in, because it starts as a plant rather than a barrel, and it carries none of the fluorinated chemistry that the shoe industry uses for water repellency. On the way out it is more complicated: PLA breaks down properly in industrial composting conditions, and what it does in ordinary soil over long periods is exactly the kind of thing we are not going to guess at. That is part of what our research with universities and colleges is for.

Is the upper made of mushrooms?

No, and we are careful about this one. The upper is a grown sheet called Hyphalite whose main ingredients are wood cellulose and natural rubber, with a fungal component in it. It is not a sheet of mushroom and we do not call it mushroom leather. The exact share of the fungal component is a number we are still asking our supplier for.

How durable is it?

Natural materials are tougher than people expect. Hemp, organic cotton and natural rubber are all robust and flexible, and natural rubber actually hardens at the exact spot where it is about to tear. As with any shoe, how long it lasts comes from the material and the construction together, and from whether you look after it.

Will it fall apart or start decomposing while I wear it?

No. The materials are stable in normal wear. People ask this because of the end of life question, and those are two different things: a shoe sitting in soil for years and a shoe on your foot in the rain are not the same situation.

Are plant-based shoes biodegradable?

We do not say that word, because it has a specific legal meaning and proving it for a whole shoe takes evidence we do not have yet. What happens at the end of a Nooch is something we do not know yet. We work with universities and colleges to find out, and we publish what we learn, whatever it says.

Can I bury my shoes in the garden?

Please do not. It would not prove anything, you would lose the shoes, and the honest answer is that we do not yet know enough about what happens. When you have worn them out, send them back instead. You get 12.50 euro towards the next pair and the old pair goes into the research.

THE BETTER OPTION

Eight plants. Made after you order it, never before.

See The 269, Harvest #4

Read next

  • ARTIKEL

    What a free return really costs

    Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.

  • ARTIKEL

    How to clean your Noochies

    A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...

  • ARTIKEL

    Life with a Noochie

    What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.