Durable vs sustainable shoes: is longer-lasting always better?
A shoe that lasts longer is not automatically more sustainable. What makes a shoe last can make its end harder. What we checked, and five questions to ask any brand.
Not always. A shoe that lasts longer spreads its footprint over more wears, and that counts. But the things that make a shoe last (a hide that cannot rot, rubber that cannot be melted, parts glued so they cannot come apart) are often the things that make its end difficult.
Durable and sustainable are two questions. Most claims answer one.
Why longer-lasting usually does help
Every pair has a footprint before you take a step. A well-known MIT study of a conventional running shoe counted 65 parts, 360 process steps and about 14 kg of CO2e per pair, give or take 2.7 kg (Cheah et al., 2013). Wear a pair twice as long and you need roughly half as many of them. The industry's own testing body says it directly: a product with an extended lifespan will have a lower impact per wear or use (SATRA, 2023).
One caution. A 2026 review of durability in fashion finds a gap between how important durability is thought to be and how it is put into practice, with limited quantitative integration into life cycle assessment (Costanzo et al., 2026). So treat any exact "lasts X times longer, saves Y" with some salt.
What makes a shoe last
Leather. Tanning is what turns a hide into leather: it stabilises the fibres so they cannot putrefy (Esquerra-Resa et al., 2022). About 85 per cent of the world's hides are chrome-tanned. Chromium(III), the form used, is stable, but it can oxidise to chromium(VI), which is hazardous and carcinogenic (Bonilla-Espadas et al., 2024). EU waste rules allow leather waste and chrome shavings to be landfilled or incinerated (same source).
Conventional rubber. Raw rubber goes tacky in the heat. Charles Goodyear's fix, patented by 1844, is vulcanisation: tie the long strands together and the rubber keeps its shape. Vulcanisation, like the curing of other thermosetting polymers, is generally irreversible. Cured rubber does not melt and flow again the way a thermoplastic does.
Everything glued together. A shoe can contain up to forty different materials, held together so they survive years of flexing. RIVM puts it at up to hundreds of parts and up to 45 materials, usually glued and stitched. Separating them again is the problem: around 95 per cent of the pairs made end up in landfill (Loughborough University, 2013).
| Material | What makes it last | What that does at the end |
|---|---|---|
| Chrome-tanned leather | Tanning stabilises the fibres so they cannot putrefy | Chromium in the waste; EU rules still allow landfill or incineration |
| Conventional vulcanised rubber | Cross-linked strands keep the shape | Generally irreversible: it does not melt and reform |
| Many glued materials | Parts are bonded to survive flexing | Hard to separate, hard to recycle; about 95 per cent of pairs end up in landfill |
Where the two questions pull apart
The property you buy durability with is "resists being broken down". It works in the wardrobe, and it works just as well in the ground.
That does not make the answer "build shoes that fall apart". A shoe that dies in a season is replaced, and the footprint of making it repeats. What to look for is durability that comes from design: a sole you can replace, parts you can separate, fewer materials. Durability that comes from adding something hard to remove is a gamble at the other end.

This part is our reasoning, not a study.
Five questions to ask any brand that says "built to last"
- Lasts how long, measured how? A number with a test method, or it is a slogan.
- What, material by material, gives it that life?
- What happens to those materials at the end, and who does it? "Recyclable" needs a place that actually recycles it.
- Can it be repaired or resoled, and by whom?
- Where is the evidence published? A claim without a source is an opinion.
Where we stand
We make shoes, so these questions apply to us too.
We don't put a lifespan figure on ours here. Our sole is natural-rubber based and contains no plastic. Whether a sole like that breaks down, and how long it takes, we don't know yet. We work with universities and colleges to research and improve our materials, and students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university). We will publish what we learn, whatever it says. There is no hide in our shoes.
We have also been burying a worn pair in a garden since April 2026. This is informal: photos only, no weighing, no control sample, and the pair was dug up several times to take them. After about seven months the upper had torn open in places, the lining was gone and a plant stem was growing through the collar. The sole wall had turned brown, but the tread was still complete and nothing had come apart in layers. In this pair the sole outlasted the upper. That does not tell us how long the sole takes, or whether anything is left behind. That is what further research is for.



A worn pair buried in a Dutch garden. Informal test.
What happens to a shoe once it is worn out is a separate question: what happens to worn-out shoes. Both sit inside a bigger map, how sustainable are your shoes, really?
Every part is on the published bill of materials. If something there does not match what we wrote, tell us.
Frequently asked questions about durable shoes
Is a longer-lasting shoe always better for the environment?
No. A longer life spreads the footprint of making it over more wears, which helps. But if the durability comes from materials that are hard to separate or break down, part of the benefit is given back at the end. How much has rarely been quantified.
Why can't a worn-out conventional rubber sole just be melted down?
Conventionally vulcanised, or cross-linked, rubber is a thermoset. Its strands are tied together permanently, so heat does not make it flow again the way it does with a thermoplastic.
What is the problem with chrome-tanned leather at its end?
The chromium. Chromium(III) is stable, but it can oxidise to carcinogenic chromium(VI) under some conditions, and EU waste rules still allow such waste to be landfilled or incinerated.
How do I check a durability claim?
Ask the five questions above. If the answer to the first is not a number and a test method, it is a slogan.
Sources
- Cheah et al., Journal of Cleaner Production 44 (2013)
- SATRA Bulletin, February 2023
- Costanzo et al., Cleaner Environmental Systems 21 (2026)
- Esquerra-Resa et al., JALCA 117 (2022)
- Bonilla-Espadas et al., Microorganisms 12(5):1029 (2024)
- Vulcanization
- RIVM 2026-0099
- Loughborough University, 2013
Read next
-
ARTIKEL
What a free return really costs
Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.
-
ARTIKEL
How to clean your Noochies
A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...
-
ARTIKEL
Life with a Noochie
What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.