Do plant-based shoes really return to nature?
Most shoes are built to resist nature. We stopped using the word everyone wants to hear, and asked a better question instead.
Some parts return quickly, some take years, and the honest answer is more complicated than most sustainability labels suggest. That is exactly why we stopped printing the word biodegradable and started asking a better question: what happens when a shoe reaches the end of its life?
The 30-second version
In a hurry? Here is the short answer.
A Nooch is made from eight plants and a fungus, with one bio-based plastic part we are open about. No animal leather, no fossil plastic, built for the biological cycle rather than the landfill.
What we do not claim is that a finished shoe meets any scientific definition of the word biodegradable. We do not claim to know what happens at the end either. Nature is not a laboratory. A soil test is a simplification of something with far more moving parts than any test can hold.
So we do not work towards a finish line. We work from a principle: nature makes nothing it cannot take care of. Everything that grew has a way back. The things with no way back are the things we invented. Build a shoe out of what nature already knows how to handle and you are at least asking the right question.
Then you keep working. We work with universities and colleges, and students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university). Not to be handed a certificate but to find out what actually happens, and we publish what we learn, whatever it says. The rest of this page is why that distinction matters, and what we can and cannot prove.
Why most shoes were never designed for nature
Most shoes are a mix of plastic, synthetic rubber, petroleum-based foam and chemical glue, engineered to resist water, bacteria, fungi and rot. Which is another way of saying they are engineered to resist nature itself. A Nooch starts from the opposite question: not how do we make a shoe last forever, but what happens when it is finally worn out. Everything on this page follows from that one switch.
The word is a test, not a property
Biodegradable sounds like a description of a material. It is not. It is the name of an exam, and the exam has a room, a temperature and a clock.
The main European exam is EN 13432. To pass, at least 90 per cent of the material's carbon has to turn into CO2 within 180 days, at 58 degrees. There is a second exam for soil, EN 17033, which is gentler: 90 per cent within two years, at around 25 degrees.
Read those numbers again. 58 degrees is hotter than a hot shower. No forest floor is ever 58 degrees. No garden is. That temperature only exists inside an industrial composting plant, which is a machine. So the headline test for biodegradable is not a test of whether something returns to nature. It is a test of whether a machine can digest it on schedule.
That is a useful thing to measure. It is just not the thing most people think they are reading.
A tree would fail this exam
Take a thick piece of oak and bury it under the rules of EN 13432. It will not hit 90 per cent in 180 days. Wood is held together by lignin, which is deliberately hard for microbes to take apart. That is why trees can stand up for two hundred years.
By the letter of the standard, that oak is not biodegradable. A cornstarch bag is. Nobody looks at a fallen branch in a wood and calls it pollution, and nothing about that branch is a failure. The whole time it lies there it is food: for fungi, for insects, for the soil. It takes part in nature long before it disappears.
This is the problem in one image. The standard is a technical label, written for industrial conditions and a fixed deadline, and we are applying it to a natural system that has never cared about deadlines.
Why we are careful with that word
Not the process, we are more committed to that than ever. The word. A 2020 study by the European Commission found that more than half of environmental claims on the EU market were vague, misleading or unfounded, and that four in ten were entirely unproven. Newer EU consumer rules now treat words like biodegradable as claims you have to substantiate, not decorate a label with.
The failure is almost always the same: a label with no timeframe, no conditions and no test behind it.
Honest disclosure: we said it too
We used to say biodegradable. We started in 2017. We asked our suppliers for materials that broke down, and they showed us certificates. These were credible companies and genuine people trying to do something good, so there was no reason to doubt them.
What we learned later is subtler than a broken promise: a certificate for a single material is not the same thing as proving that a whole shoe returns to real, uncontrolled soil. The materials were sound. The claim was just bigger than the paperwork underneath it.
When we said it, we meant the plain human thing: nature will take care of it. Officially the word is not a feeling, it is a test. We could not prove the official version for a whole shoe, so we stopped, and we will not start again until somebody who is not us has done the work.
Our sole is the slow part, and we do not yet know how slow
We have no test result for the outsole, so we do not call it biodegradable. What we can say is why it is the part to watch.
Natural rubber, as it comes out of the tree, is food. Soil is full of bacteria and fungi that break it down and use it as a source of carbon and energy. They turn up exactly where you would guess, in the ground around rubber trees, and scientists have been documenting them since 1928.
A finished sole is not raw sap. It has to survive years of walking, wet pavements and your full body weight on one heel, and that makes it far tougher than the material it started as. A sole that holds up for years and one that falls apart in a season are two different products. We chose the one that lasts, because a shoe that dies early is the bigger waste.
There is a datapoint worth knowing, and worth being precise about. In published soil-burial work, a thin disk of natural rubber lost about a sixth of its weight in eight months. That is a thin disk in a study, not a sole. Turning that number into a prediction about our shoe would be exactly the kind of arithmetic that got the word biodegradable into trouble in the first place. That is what our research with universities and colleges is for. An informal burial of a worn pair, photos only, is described in durable vs sustainable shoes.
The bio-based part that is still plastic
One part of a Nooch is plastic: a thin layer inside the sole called the strobel. It is PLA, made from plant sugar rather than oil.
Under EU law, bio-based plastic is still plastic. So we do not say plastic-free. We say free of fossil plastic, because that is what is true.
PLA is also the clearest example of how conditional all of this is. It breaks down in two steps. First water has to cut the chains, then microbes eat the pieces. The first step needs heat. Above roughly 60 degrees the polymer softens and water gets in, and the process starts. Below that it stays rigid and water mostly stays out.
So the same piece of PLA passes the industrial exam in a composting plant and does almost nothing in a cool garden. Same material. Different room. Any sentence about PLA that leaves out the room is marketing.
Why proving it in soil is so hard
The honest test for does this return to nature is a soil burial test. You bury the sample and measure the CO2 coming out of it. It sounds simple. It is not.
Soil breathes on its own, constantly, and far louder than your sample. Picking your material's CO2 out of that background is like trying to hear one voice in a full stadium. The test runs for up to two years. The answer depends on which soil, how wet it is, how warm it is and which microbes happen to live there, which means two careful labs can get two different numbers and both be right.
And there is a structural problem on top. These standards test one material at a time. A shoe is many materials bonded together. There is no valid way to put a whole shoe in the test and get a meaningful number out, which is why anyone claiming a biodegradable shoe is making a claim the test cannot actually support.
One last distinction worth keeping. Falling apart is not disappearing. A material can break into fragments and still be entirely present. The standards separate those two words on purpose, and so do we.
The real question: fragments or food?
There is plastic sold as biodegradable that technically passes a test. The catch is how. A lot of it simply breaks into pieces so small they fall below what anyone can detect, and then we call it gone. It is not gone. It is microplastic, scattered through soil and water, just too small to see. And not only out there. In 2022, researchers in Amsterdam went looking for these particles in human blood and found them, the first time anyone had shown that plastic this small ends up circulating inside us.
The EU saw through this. In 2021 it banned oxo-degradable plastic across the bloc, exactly because it does not return to anything. It only fragments into microplastics that stay in the environment.
So two very different endings hide under one word. One breaks into bits too small to find. The other becomes food. Plant materials are the second kind, and that is the whole reason to build a shoe out of them.
It does not only happen at the end
A shoe is also wearing away the whole time you have it on, whether you mean it to or not.
Every step grinds a little off the sole. On an ordinary shoe that sole is synthetic, so what rubs off is microplastic, left on the pavement, washed into drains, lifted into the air. Shoe soles are now counted among the everyday sources of microplastic pollution, shed not at the end of a shoe's life but across all of it, one step at a time.
A plant shoe wears down too. Nothing escapes friction. But what it leaves on the path behind you is plant matter, not plastic. That difference does not wait for the end. It is happening on every walk.
The oldest shoe ever found is 5,500 years old
In a cave in Armenia, archaeologists once dug up a shoe. One piece of cowhide, laced front and back, shaped to a right foot, still stuffed with the grass someone packed into it. It was 5,500 years old, older than the pyramids, and barely worn out.
It lasted partly because the cave stayed cool and dry and the shoe sat sealed under layers of sheep dung. But it lasted at all because of what it was. Leather, tanned to resist the exact thing this whole page is about: rot, microbes, going back to the soil. Tanning is, in a way, the craft of stopping a hide from returning to nature.
So there is a quiet split at the heart of footwear. One kind of shoe is built to outlast you by thousands of years. The other is built to come home. We are trying, on purpose, to make the second kind.
Is returning to nature always the right goal?
Not necessarily, and we take the counter-argument seriously. A metal bicycle should not be buried. Neither should a smartphone. Returning to nature only earns its place when the material genuinely belongs in the biological cycle rather than the technical one, where the goal is to keep it in use. A Nooch sits firmly in the biological cycle. Plant fibres and natural rubber are not things you want to keep forever in a loop of factories. They came from the ground.
What we are doing next
We are shoemakers, entrepreneurs and innovators, not scientists. So rather than mark our own homework, we work with universities and colleges on how our materials behave in soil and which end-of-life genuinely makes sense. Students at Wageningen University have looked at the materials in our shoes in student projects (not official publications of the university). Every answer so far has produced a better question.
We are also not standing still, and none of what follows is a promise on a label. It is the workbench. We are looking at whether adding PHA, a material some of our partners work with, could help the slow parts along. We are experimenting with bokashi, the Japanese way of fermenting organic matter down into the soil. And in the least scientific and most honest experiment of all, one of us has a worn-out pair buried in the garden right now, just to watch what really happens.
What we know today
We do not know how long every part of a Nooch takes to return to nature. Anyone who claims that kind of certainty is pretending, and we would rather be the brand that says so.
What we can tell you is exactly what it is made of. A natural-rubber based sole, a grown sheet of wood cellulose and natural rubber with a fungal component for the upper, hemp, organic cotton, flax and kenaf through the rest, soy ink on top, and one part, the thin strobel layer under the insole, that is PLA spun from corn starch and is still a plastic. No animal leather. Nothing engineered to fight nature. And a passport on every box that tells you which of those went into your pair.
Two neighbouring questions have their own pages: whether a longer-lasting shoe is a better one, in durable vs sustainable shoes, and what happens to a shoe once it is worn out, in what happens to worn-out shoes.
Frequently asked questions about plant-based shoes and biodegradability
Do plant-based shoes return to nature?
Some of their materials can, given time and the right conditions, and the speed differs enormously between a cotton lace and a rubber sole. The catch is that most shoes sold as plant-based still hide a synthetic sole, thread or glue that never returns at all. Ours is built the other way, with one bio-based plastic part we name rather than hide.
Is a Nooch shoe biodegradable?
We do not use that word for our shoes. It is a regulated lab term, and we would rather not borrow it than borrow it badly. We work with universities and colleges to find out what happens at the end of a Nooch, and we publish what we learn, whatever it says.
Why can you not just test the whole shoe?
Because the standards do not work that way. EN 13432 and EN 17033 test one homogeneous material at a time, under fixed conditions, against a reference. A shoe is many materials bonded together, so there is no valid way to put one in the test and get a meaningful number out. Anyone selling a certified biodegradable shoe is stretching a certificate that was issued for a single material.
Is bio-based the same as biodegradable?
No, and this is the most common mix-up. Bio-based says where the carbon came from. Biodegradable says what happens at the end. The PLA in our strobel layer is bio-based, made from plant sugar rather than oil, and under EU law it is still a plastic. Those are two separate questions and a material can answer yes to one and no to the other.
Can I bury or compost my shoes in the garden?
We do not give you a disposal instruction, and here is the honest reason. We do not yet know enough to tell you what would happen, including to the sole. So we would rather take responsibility for the end of life ourselves. Send a worn-out pair back and you get 12.50 euro towards the next one, and the old pair goes into the research.
Which part of a plant-based shoe takes longest?
As far as we can tell, the sole. Natural rubber comes from a tree and soil microbes can work on it, but a sole built to last for years is much tougher than the raw material, so it is likely the slowest part. How long a finished sole takes is exactly what our research with universities and colleges is for, and until there is an answer we are not putting a number on it.
Read next
-
ARTICLE
What a free return really costs
Order three sizes, send two back. It is sold as service. The van is the small part of the bill.
-
ARTICLE
How to clean your Noochies
A damp cloth, a little natural soap, and never the washing machine. Plus the care products we recommend, and what to do when something...
-
ARTICLE
Life with a Noochie
What it costs and why, how to find your size, how to clean your Noochies, and what happens when they are worn out.